ODPEM chief saw trouble long before audit
Originally published by Jamaica Observer Read the original
INTERNAL Office of Disaster Preparedness and Emergency Management (ODPEM) correspondence seen by the Jamaica Observer show that Director General Commander Alvin Gayle had long held concerns about several of the issues raised by the auditor general in a report tabled in Parliament last Tuesday.
In its report the Auditor General Department said its team members who inspected warehouses holding Hurricane Melissa relief supplies found 359 boxes of crackers past their best-before dates, insects on the packaging of some consumables, and 15 unopened containers that had not been recorded in ODPEM’s inventory, exposing serious gaps in how the agency accounted for and safeguarded donated goods.
The report also identified approximately $780 million in shipments that were not included in the donation schedules maintained by ODPEM.
The auditor general also raised concerns about the conditions in which relief supplies were being stored, given the presence of insects on the packaging of some consumable items.
Additionally, the inspection exposed a basic problem with the agency’s record-keeping. ODPEM did not provide auditors with store records showing the quantities of goods that should have been in Warehouse 3. This meant the auditors could not compare what they physically counted with the supplies recorded as received since November 2025 or those distributed during the period under review.
Sunday Observer sources have since pointed to repeated efforts by Gayle to address the issues before the auditor general’s report.
These include a memo dated June 22 in which Gayle wrote to the entity’s then logistics manager seeking urgent information on the agency’s readiness for the 2026 Atlantic hurricane season.
In the memo Gayle pointed to a previous correspondence one month earlier in which he had already requested the information which had not been submitted by the logistics manager.
“Reference is made to my memorandum dated May 21, 2026, directing the completion and submission of the Hurricane Inventory Template to facilitate the consolidation and verification of the office’s operational readiness inventory for the 2026 Atlantic Hurricane Season.
“A review of your submission has revealed that the information provided was materially incomplete and required significant intervention by the Office of the Director General to address critical gaps. This situation is both disappointing and unacceptable,” said Gayle in the June memo.
He pointed out that the initial response from the logistics manager failed to adequately capture or provide the required information relating to all Starlink devices, including their current locations, operational status, assigned custodians, deployment details, and other relevant tracking information;
GAYLE... ODPEM’s mandate requires the organisation to maintain effective systems for the management, control and accountability of resources entrusted to it
Gayle added that the logistics manager failed to provide generator inventories, including donor information, generator capacities, current locations, operational status, and additional information required under the General Stores section, including inventory balances, stock status, and other supporting details necessary for effective operational planning and reporting. “The purpose of the exercise was to provide the Director General’s Office with a comprehensive and accurate inventory position. It is therefore unacceptable that such fundamental omissions were not identified and addressed prior to submission. The information requested falls squarely within your remit and should already have been known, maintained, and readily available through established inventory management processes and systems. “The fact that the Office of the Director General found these significant gaps in the records that have been provided by you demonstrates a serious deficiency in the preparation, verification, and quality assurance of the submission,” added Gayle. He directed the logistics manager to immediately review the inventory management and reporting processes within the Logistics Unit and provide a written report to include: The reasons for the incomplete submission; the measures being implemented to ensure inventory records are maintained accurately and in real time; the quality assurance mechanisms that would be instituted to prevent a recurrence of this issue and; any outstanding inventory information that remains to be verified. “The maintenance of accurate inventory records is a fundamental operational requirement, particularly in the context of disaster preparedness, emergency response, donor accountability, and audit compliance. I expect immediate corrective action and sustained improvement in this regard. Please treat this matter with the urgency and seriousness it warrants,” said Gayle. Days later Gayle again wrote to the logistics manager expressing concern about the receipt, storage, issue and status of the generators donated by the Government of Mexico to Jamaica following Hurricane Melissa in October 2025. The ODPEM director general demanded details on when the generators were received, amount issued and how many were still in storage. By August an obviously frustrated Gayle wrote to the logistics manager expressing displeasure over the management of the department and his failure to maintain proper records of the supplies and donated items donated to ODPEM. “These matters fell directly within the core responsibilities of the logistics manager, particularly the maintenance of accurate and up-to-date inventory records, the proper accounting for equipment and supplies received and distributed during disaster and relief operations, and the preparation and maintenance of records showing the final disposition of items donated by local and international partners. “ODPEM’s mandate requires the organisation to maintain effective systems for the management, control, and accountability of resources entrusted to it in support of national disaster preparedness, emergency response and relief operations. Proper accountability for these resources is therefore fundamental to the effective discharge of that mandate and to safeguarding the wider public interest,” said Gayle to the logistics manager who resigned from ODPEM in August.