Prosecutors resume push for jailhouse statement to be tendered into evidence
Originally published by Jamaica Observer Read the original
AFTER almost a week in limbo, prosecutors in the ongoing trial of 25 alleged members of the Tesha Miller faction of the Klansman Gang resumed their push for a statement collected from the accused Charles McLeary two days after a double murder in John’s Hall, Clarendon in June 2020 to be tendered and admitted into evidence.
The proceedings had been limping after the defence mounted fierce objections to the prosecution tendering the six-page document and requested that extracts from station diaries from the Lionel Town, Chapelton and May Pen police stations be furnished in respect of the accused men. Particular interest surrounded the Lionel Town station diary reflecting the particulars of McLeary’s time there.
According to prosecutors, McLeary — along with co-accused Bjourn Thomas, Sharn Gilzene, Conroy Cadogan and Kemar Francis — knowingly facilitated the commission of a serious offence — the murder of Jermaine Jones and Allen Cameron on June 26, 2020 — and were taken into custody following a highway chase and the two motor cars in which they were travelling in seized. The accused men allegedly ambushed and opened fire on Jones and Cameron who were travelling in a Toyota Hiace bus, killing them.
However, a statement which was collected while McLeary was in custody at the Lionel Town Police Station late into the night of the 26th has been a bone of contention.
A deputy superintendent of police assigned to the Major Investigative Division (MID), in taking the stand to give evidence of his interactions with McLeary that night, said he had simply observed the taking of the statement by the detective sergeant who spoke with McLeary. He maintained that the statement was simply McLeary’s “account of his whereabouts” at the time of the murders. However, when the prosecution made an application at that time to have that statement read into the records of the court, the defence objected and raised concerns about the “voluntariness” and the “fairness” of the statement, contending that it was taken “in the dead of night” and while McLeary was “a suspect” and not charged.
During a voir dire (trial within a trial during which admissibility of evidence is determined) which lasted several hours, defence attorneys had grilled the senior cop who insisted that “no threat” or “promise” was made to McLeary to have him produce the statement, and that the accused man had not been charged for the crime even after he had left the station following the exercise. He further told the acting deputy director of public prosecutions leading the evidence that he did not know McLeary prior, stating that up to the point of that statement being taken, there had been no eyewitness accounts of the crime that he was aware of.
The prosecution which should have made their own submissions on November 10 to the trial judge in their quest to have the document — which was “marked for identification” — tendered and admitted into evidence, were only able to do so on Wednesday after the acting deputy director of public prosecutions leading the evidence furnished the diaries for two of the three stations. In respect of Lionel Town, only the prisoner in custody book relevant to McLeary’s time at the station had been found.
Attorney Javed Grant who represents McLeary, in making submissions in support of his objection, maintained that the Crown had not discharged its burden to prove the voluntariness and fairness in the taking of the statement by cops and had only relied on the one witness during the voir dire.
“The sole witness could not speak to what transpired before he arrived at the station before the taking of the statement,” Grant said, while arguing that the prosecution has also failed to supply evidence of all interactions had by McLeary with other law enforcers.
“The officer did his best to give the impression that the statement was not a confession but was a ‘whereabouts’ statement. This sole witness also tried his very best to give the court the impression that at the time when the statement was being taken from Mr McLeary, he was not a suspect, but all the actions of the police were to the contrary. I will firmly submit that at the time the statement was being taken Mr McLeary was in fact a suspect or was being treated as a suspect,” Grant said. He argued further that the police had not informed McLeary of his rights to legal representation as required.
“It cannot be said that the men, and in particular Mr McLeary, were not being treated as suspects. It is my respectful submission that the Crown has not satisfied the court that the statement was voluntary and even if the court should decide it was voluntary, the overarching criterion of fairness was not satisfied,” Grant contended.
Wednesday, the Crown in making its submissions, said the court could not base its decision on the evidence from the voir dire alone, but was bound to consider other evidence relating to the counts including the evidence of the cop who processed the scene, the lawman who testified of the apprehension of the men, and the cop who detailed how the investigations began and who later identified McLeary in the docks during his testimony.
In relation to the disputed statement, the prosecutor contended that “no issue could be taken” as to whether or not it accounted for his whereabouts, as the cop had indicated that on the 26th when it was given he was still in the “information gathering stage” and McLeary had not been cautioned until the 28th when after a search of one of the vehicles, guns were found.
He pointed out that there was no complaint of mistreatment or request for refreshment made by McLeary in his six-page statement.
Doubling down, the prosecutor in referencing the Judges’ Rules — administrative guidelines used by the Jamaica Constabulary to govern how police officers question suspects and collect voluntary statements — said when the statement was recorded the cops were at the first stage of the probe.
“There is nothing to suggest Mr McLeary was charged before the 28th,” he said before going on to note that “whether a person is suspected or whether a person is a suspect in the eyes of the law are two separate things”. He added that up until, or unless, the police have reasonable grounds for suspecting that a person has committed an offence, there is no need for a caution and where a person is charged, it requires that a caution is administered before any questions are asked.
In the case of McLeary, he said the accused had given the statement voluntarily and made no admission of guilt in it.
Justice Palmer is expected to make his ruling today after the defence replies to the submissions by the Crown.