Tufton outlines measures to tackle shortcomings in the public health sector following worrying review
Originally published by Jamaica Observer Read the original
MINISTER of Health and Wellness Dr Christopher Tufton has pointed to a raft of measures that is being implemented to address the “systemic problems” besetting the country’s ailing health-care sector.
Tufton outlined the measures in Parliament on Tuesday after he tabled a report which detailed shocking shortcomings faced by patients including delayed admission and treatment, late diagnosis, lack of treatment, long waiting lists and discourteous staff. These were among more than 1,000 client (patient) complaints recorded at hospitals across Jamaica’s four Regional Health Authorities (RHAs) during the first quarter of the year.
The Jamaica Observer reported on the review findings on Wednesday, highlighting that just over 10 per cent of the complaints have been cleared up. The findings are contained in a 50-page Ministry of Health and Wellness Report titled, ‘Institutional Performance Review’ that was ordered by Tufton.
Tufton had vowed to be open and transparent when he ordered the review, and on Tuesday he said it was “self-imposed”.
“This is a new effort that we’re embarking on. I know it lends fodder for those who like to criticise because there’s a lot to criticise here,” Tufton said at the conclusion of his presentation, a seeming acknowledgement of the numerous deficiencies in the public health-care system.
Tufton pointed to the health ministry’s implementation of the accountability framework scorecard, which rates 13 public health entities against 18 governance and accountability indicators, and the client care connect, which managed 1,045 client feedback cases across the four RHAs. He suggested the review also offered a blueprint for the way forward.
By way of action, he said all regional health authorities have been mandated to implement plans to clear their backlog of open cases, and expand the QR Code feedback system launched by the South East Regional Health Authority so every patient can be heard and every concern tracked to solution.
The minister said that by January 2027, the portfolio score should reach at least 60 per cent and one in four client cases should be resolved within the quarter.
“By April 2027, no entity should remain in the critical category and at least half of all cases should be resolved,” he stated.
Beginning in the 2027/28 fiscal year, the service level agreements with each regional health authority will incorporate the framework indicators and targets for resolving patient concerns.
“We will follow the resources to ensure that primary healthcare and prevention gets adequate support at the level of the regional authorities,” Tufton assured.
He also committed to meet personally with board chairs and each will be asked to submit a 90-day recovery plan by November 30 and report monthly to the health ministry. “Where there is no measureable improvement by January, the performance of the board will be reviewed,” Tufton said.
For hospitals with the highest number of patient complaints, beginning with Cornwall Regional, St Ann’s Bay and Kingston Public, the ministry will meet with the board chairs, regional directors and chief executive officers and require reviews of the level of the individual departments. “This is to identify which units are struggling and why, and learn from those that are doing well,” said Tufton.
He highlighted that Cornwall Regional Hospital was doing well in a few areas. “Their physiotherapy department is excellent, their dialysis department is world class. They don’t keep patients in A&E, they triage them to wards. These are examples that we could teach many other institutions,” said the minister.
Regarding Cornwall Regional, he was careful to point out that the review was not a condemnation of an entire institution, but rather “it is recognising the weaknesses and correcting them”.
He told the Parliament that the review represents the first integrated assessment of two principal mechanisms through which the ministry measures organisational performance and accountability. Pointing out that government mechanisms were already in place to do that, Tufton explained that “we have come up with a format because we believe it agitates more aggressively for the value for money preposition”.
The accountability framework scorecard evaluated 13 public health entities against 18 governance, leadership and accountability indicators, while the client care connect tracked and monitored over 1,000 patient feedback cases across the four regional health authorities.
“Taken together, these instruments provide a comprehensive review of how well our institutions are governed, how effectively they respond to the public they serve, and where improvements are required, to strengthen performance and public trust,” said Tufton.
Significantly, the review found that no regional health authority was performing at the highest level on both governance and client (patient) experience.
“While some institutions demonstrate strong compliance on governance requirements, that strength is not always reflected in the patient experience,” Tufton acknowledged. He pointed to the North East Regional Health Authority as an example, noting that it achieved the highest governance score in the portfolio, yet it resolved less than one per cent of the client cases reported during the review period.
“That finding should give us pause because accountability is not measured by the number of reports that we produce, the meetings we hold, or the policies we approve. Accountability is measured by outcomes, it is measured by whether concerns are addressed, whether service is improved and whether citizens feel heard”.
Meanwhile, Tufton acknowledged that nearly 90 per cent of patient complaints remain unresolved and identified several recurring challenges across the public health portfolio. These relate primarily to management and client services. Monthly performance reporting was flagged as a weakness, so too the absence of timely audited financial statements; digital transformation initiatives were progressing too slowly, and inconsistent measurement of governance breaches was also present. Of particular concern is that complaint resolution mechanisms lacked the responsiveness that citizens expect and deserve.
Tufton argued that these are not merely administrative concerns. He argued that “unresolved complaints represent a missed opportunity to learn, delayed reports constrained decision-making, while weaknesses in governance increase risks, and inefficiency consumes resources that could be directed to patient care”.