Music

Willow Smith’s Amerie Cover Gets A Vocal Coach’s Defense After Intense Online Roasting

Nov 19, 2026 · Nolan Strong

Originally published by AllHipHop Read the original

Willow Smith’s Amerie Cover Gets A Vocal Coach’s Defense After Intense Online Roasting

Willow Smith‘s much-debated Amerie cover has a defender listening for something beyond a flawless copy of the original: a vocal coach who hears deliberate choices in her delivery.

Adam Ross Glickman weighed in under BBC Radio 1’s Instagram clip of Willow performing “1 Thing,” arguing that a shift in her voice showed control rather than a mistake.

“I’m hearing a singer PLAYING with her voice, live. That flip into chest?? That’s control, not an accident,” he wrote in a comment.

Glickman’s assessment appeared as listeners continued debating the performance. Some commenters praised Willow for putting her own stamp on the song, while others questioned whether the selection suited her voice.

The coach’s defense focused specifically on her move into chest voice. Where other listeners heard imperfections, he described experimentation and singled out that shift as evidence of her vocal control.

Glickman teaches voice and performance in New York. His official coaching page lists a musical theater degree from Millikin University, membership in the National Association of Teachers of Singing and experience performing on the national tour of The Sound of Music.

Willow’s BBC session also included “Unconditional” and the new song “Circles.” The station posted its “1 Thing” clip Tuesday.

Amerie’s original recording had its own distinct musical foundation. In an MVRemix interview, she explained that she and producer Rich Harrison deliberately drew on Washington, D.C.’s go-go sound.

They had explored that influence at a slower pace on her first album before returning to it with a faster track. Amerie said both artists wanted their D.C. roots reflected in the music.

The track appeared on Amerie’s second album, Touch, released in 2005.

Willow, meanwhile, has spent years moving beyond the pop sound of her 2010 breakthrough “Whip My Hair.” As AllHipHop previously reported, her later work has ranged through pop-punk, heavier rock and jazz.

Her 2022 album Coping Mechanism drew on punk, grunge and metal. This year’s The Thread followed February’s Petal Rock Black and reunited her with producer Chris Greatti.

In an interview with Who What Wear, Willow described The Thread as a devotional project connecting the different stages of her life and music.

← All stories
Built with adlens