Music

YNW Melly Seeks To Keep Gang Testimony Out Of Murder Retrial

Nov 17, 2026 · Mike Winslow

Originally published by AllHipHop Read the original

YNW Melly Seeks To Keep Gang Testimony Out Of Murder Retrial

YNW Melly wants jurors kept away from gang testimony, his lawyers say, which never explained the killings prosecutors have charged him with.

His defense is asking a Broward County judge to exclude gang evidence and related expert testimony from his double-murder retrial.

Attorneys Carey Haughwout and Drew Findling filed the eight-page motion November 13. Their argument targets the gap between describing an alleged gang affiliation and proving the murders served a gang’s interests.

“The gang-related evidence at the first trial was lengthy, prejudicial, and, most importantly, bore no connection to the alleged murders,” the defense wrote.

The lawyers focus on Detective Polo’s earlier testimony about the Bloods and G-Shine, including their origins, rules and hierarchy. They say he interpreted photographs, conversations and symbols without tying that material to the charged shootings.

“However, at no point did Detective Polo connect the gang-related evidence to the allegations in this case,” the defense wrote.

Prosecutors have argued that gang evidence helps explain motive and intent. The defense filing quotes the state’s response to an earlier motion as calling it “directly relevant to the State’s theory of the case regarding motive and intent, regardless of potential sentence.”

The new request also leans on an earlier evidence ruling. According to the defense, Judge John Murphy’s December 20, 2023 order already excluded most gang-related digital material, including emails, text messages and expert interpretations of those records.

Melly faces two first-degree murder charges in the October 26, 2018 deaths of fellow rappers YNW Sakchaser and YNW Juvy. Prosecutors allege the men were shot inside a vehicle before the scene was staged as a drive-by shooting.

Melly has pleaded not guilty. His first trial ended with a deadlocked jury in July 2023, and prosecutors are seeking the death penalty if he is convicted.

The evidentiary fight comes as his team continues preparing for the retrial. The indictment includes an allegation that the killings benefited, promoted or furthered a criminal gang, which the defense argues cannot justify unrelated testimony about gang culture. The motion warns that broad descriptions of gang practices could encourage jurors to judge Melly through stereotypes.

Jury selection is scheduled to begin January 6, 2027.

← All stories
Built with adlens